Written By
Updated May 28, 2022 10:45 PM

Having a toaster oven on your counter is a great way to harness the power of a larger standard oven without heating up your entire kitchen. These small and powerful appliances preheat incredibly quickly and cook your food in a fraction of the time, whether you’re browning a stack of toast on a busy morning before school or work or roasting a beautiful golden chicken for dinner with friends. As long as you look for a toaster oven that’s the right size and has the cooking functionality you’re looking for, such as air frying, roasting, broiling, and dehydrating, chances are you’ll rely on this trusty appliance more than your oven. These are the best toaster ovens to consider. 

How We Selected These Products 

To find the best toaster ovens for every kitchen, we started with the top small appliance brands and their most-loved products. We researched product descriptions, customer testimonials, and reviews of long-time users. In particular, we looked at the size and capacity of the ovens, their cooking versatility and practicality, wattage, and long-term durability. This list includes products for every budget, kitchen size, and culinary skill level. 

Best Toaster Ovens: Reviews and Recommendations

Best Overall: Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven

Best Overall

Built-in sensors take the guesswork out of roasting, toasting, and more when using this sleek stainless steel countertop toaster oven. Breville

Why It Made The Cut: Cutting-edge sensor technology sets this model from Breville apart from manual toaster ovens.

Specs:

  • Weight: 1 pound
  • Product Dimensions: 15.7 x 18.5 x 11 inches
  • Materials: Stainless steel

Pros:

  • Nine cooking functions
  • Element iQ system to sense cooking timing
  • 1,800-watt power

Cons:  

  • Expensive

Not only will this compact toaster oven look great in any kitchen, it also performs like a professional. The oven is designed with Breville’s Element iQ system, which consists of five quartz elements that sense the contents of the toaster oven and direct the cooking time, temperature, and heat source, to perfect your meal. For example, you can place a whole chicken inside for roasting, and set the temperature. The oven will then calculate the weight and density of the bird and adjust the cooking time accordingly for a perfectly juicy roast with crispy, golden skin. 

The 1800-watt motor makes for a super-fast preheat time, and the powerful convection fan reduces cooking time even more (compared to a traditional convection oven). The appliance’s nine cooking functions include toast, bake, roast, broil, reheat, and warm, as well as one-touch programs for toast, bagels, and pizza. You can comfortably fit six slices of toast at once, or bake a 6-cup muffin pan. Unlike many other toaster ovens, this one has a sleek and useful LCD display that indicates preheating, the selected cooking function, and the oven temperature. 

Best Budget: Mueller 4-Slice Toaster Oven

Best Budget

A pared-down but durable and reliable oven that won’t break the bank. Mueller Austria

Why It Made The Cut: This is an easy-to-use and straightforward toaster oven that’s great for small kitchens.

Specs:

  • Weight: 7.63 pounds
  • Product Dimensions: 14.84 x 8.86 x 11.85 inches
  • Materials: Stainless steel

Pros:

  • Toasts evenly
  • Temperature range 150 degrees F to 450 degrees F
  • Broiling function

Cons:  

  • Timer only goes for 30 minutes
  • Not the most high-tech option

If you don’t need fancy bells and whistles and are short on counter space, this toaster oven from Mueller will do the trick. This countertop oven has every feature you need and nothing you don’t. It’s straightforward to use with clearly labeled dials for toasting, baking, broiling, and keeping food warm. A blue indicator light lets you know when the appliance is hot, and the built-in timer chimes loudly when your toast is ready. The toaster comes with a miniature rimmed baking sheet that slides into place on the removable wire baking rack. Though this appliance doesn’t have quite as strong a construction as more expensive models, you can’t beat the price. The cost and size make this toaster the best choice for those on a budget or shoppers with small kitchens. 

Most Versatile: Ninja DT201 Foodi

Most Versatile

A fully-outfitted countertop oven that can do everything your regular oven can do, and then some. Ninja

Why It Made The Cut: An impressive array of advanced features, including 10 cooking functions and fast preheat, will save you time and optimize your meals. 

Specs:

  • Weight: 33.63 pounds
  • Product Dimensions: 17.09 x 20.22 x 13.34 inches
  • Materials: Stainless steel, plastic

Pros:

  • Ten cooking functions
  • 1,800-watt power
  • 90-second preheat

Cons: 

  • Large
  • Pricey

Ninja Foodi’s toaster oven does it all. The ten cooking functions include air frying, air roasting, baking broiling, toasting, dehydrating, and reheating, as well as one-touch programs for bagels and pizza. This is also one of the most powerful convection countertop ovens we found, with an 1,800-watt power source. It’s also spacious. You can easily prepare an entire meal for a family of four to six in this toaster oven, thanks to two levels of cooking space. There’s even enough space to roast an entire 5-pound chicken and a baking sheet of veggies at the same time. In fact, this countertop appliance can handle a 12-pound Thanksgiving turkey, so you can save your oven for plenty of pie. Despite its size, the oven heats up incredibly fast, in under two minutes. The rapid air circulation and high heat are a recipe for super crispy food without all the oil required by deep-fat frying. For added guidance, the oven is smart enough to know where your baking pans should go once you select a cooking function. 

Best for Toast: Hamilton Beach 2-in-1 Countertop Oven and Toaster

Best for Toast

Replace your toaster altogether with this oven and slot toaster combination. Hamilton Beach

Why It Made The Cut: This well-designed countertop oven doubles as a regular slot-style toaster in a pinch, making it the best choice for the toast-obsessed. 

Specs:

  • Weight: 10.9 pounds
  • Product Dimensions: 12.05 x 17.8 x 10.24 inches
  • Materials: Stainless steel

Pros:

  • Includes long toaster slots
  • Lightweight
  • Even toasting

Cons: 

  • Not as many cooking functions as other ovens
  • Smaller internal space

This smart double-duty appliance is great for busy mornings. In addition to roasting and broiling, the oven also has two extra-large toasting slots on top for evenly crisp and golden bagels and bread. It’s easy to dial in on your desired degree of toasted ness with the shade selector, so everyone can have their ideal breakfast in the morning. The oven can heat up to 450 degrees F, plus a broil function, and has a long 60-minute timer with auto shut-off for safety. The interior oven can hold a 9-inch pizza and comes with a wire rack, baking sheet, and a removable crumb tray for easy clean-up.

Best for Meat: KitchenAid Dual Convection Countertop Oven with Probe

Best for Meat

Air fry, roast, and even dehydrate with ease in this sleek all-black toaster oven. KitchenAid

Why It Made The Cut: In addition to being built for super-crisp air frying and uniform toasting, a built-in temperature probe makes it easy to perfectly cook any cut of meat. 

Specs:

  • Weight: 3 pounds
  • Product Dimensions: 16.4 x 18.5 x 13 inches
  • Materials: Metal

Pros:

  • 12 cooking settings
  • Includes air fry basket
  • Spacious interior

Cons:

  • Large
  • Expensive

If you love making centerpiece-worthy roasts of beef, lamb, chicken, and fish, you’ll love how this convection countertop oven helps you achieve the perfect internal temperature and texture without any babysitting. The oven includes a built-in temperature probe. Simply set your desired temperature, insert the probe into your food, and the oven will alert you as soon as it reaches your desired doneness. 

You can easily fit two 3.6-pound whole chickens or a 9×13-inch baking dish in the oven. It also preheats much faster than a wall oven, reaching 350 degrees F in under four minutes. The 12 built-in cooking functions include air frying, baking, broiling, dehydrating, dough proofing, reheating, roasting, and convection baking. For toast, you can dial in your desired shade. The oven also comes with a bounty of handy accessories, including an air frying basket that maximizes heat flow, a storage case for the thermometer, a baking pan with a grill rack, a removable metal roasting rack, and a removable drip and crumb tray to keep things clean. 

Things to Consider When Buying the Best Toaster Oven

Size

Before you invest in any new countertop appliance, make sure you have the counter space to spare. Measure the location in your kitchen and compare it with the product dimensions to ensure the oven will fit in your space. Keep in mind that larger ovens will offer more versatility, as you can fit whole chickens and larger baking pans inside. For smaller spaces, more compact ovens are great for toast and meals that serve one to two people.  

Cooking Functions

Newer toaster ovens offer as many as 12 cooking functions, including air frying, broiling, and reheating. You’ll most likely have to spend more for more cooking functions, but you may also be able to replace other appliances, such as a stand-alone air fryer or toaster. 

Accessories

Depending on what you plan to cook in your toaster oven, you may want some specific accessories. For example, if you like baking cakes or casseroles, it’s nice to have a baking dish that fits inside the appliance. Or, if you plan to air fry, opt for an oven that comes with a perforated or wire-style air frying basket. This maximizes airflow for even cooking and uniform crisping. 

FAQs

Q: Can I use a toaster oven instead of a normal oven?

In many cases, yes! A toaster oven works the same way as a wall oven, it’s just smaller. The smaller size can actually be an advantage, as it preheats and cooks food faster. Of course, it doesn’t have the same capacity, so if you’re cooking for a crowd, a larger oven will make things easier. 

Q: What’s the difference between a toaster oven and a microwave?

A toaster oven uses a fan and convection heat to circulate hot, dry heat around your food. This facilitates better crisping and browning. A microwave, on the other hand, uses microwaves to heat food from the outside in. This is a better bet for liquids and soft foods. Microwaves are more energy-efficient than toaster ovens. 

Q: Can I air fry in a toaster oven?

Yes! In many cases, you can use your toaster oven as an air fryer. Many of the newer toaster oven models have air fryer functions, but really all this means is high heat that circulates quickly around your food to produce crispy results without tons of oil.

Final Thoughts

If you’re looking for a durable, great-looking and highly functional toaster oven to rely on for years, you can’t go wrong with the Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven. This mid-size oven won’t dominate your kitchen space, but it will make roasting, toasting, broiling, and defrosting as straightforward as possible, thanks to the built-in smart sensors. Sure, it’s not the cheapest appliance on the market, but it will save you time, and time is money, after all!

MORE TO READ