Written By
Published Sep. 21, 2021

You don’t really think about the importance of a toilet seat until you use one that’s uncomfortable, unsanitary, or non-existent. You need a toilet seat to be both clean and comfortable. A toilet seat is generally a hinged unit, consisting of both the seat and the lid. These come in elongated (oval) and round options, and the entire unit bolts onto the toilet bowl. Typical toilet seats rest on spacers, so less of the underside of the seat comes in contact with the toilet bowl. Many seats are contoured for user comfort while they do their business.

Aside from being a pleasant place to sit, a toilet seat serves as protection from what’s inside a toilet bowl. This seat is a barrier between the user and the toilet, helping control the transfer of bacteria and other germs. We’ve done our research and have found the best toilet seats available on the market today. Keep reading to see our preferred products and why we chose them. 

How We Picked These Products

Methodology

A recent study found that people spend more time in the bathroom than they do exercising. With this stat in mind, it’s worth finding the best toilet seat to make that time comfortable. As a careful consumer and long-time product reviewer for home, gardening, and health products, there’s more to take into account than a product’s consumer rating. To determine what makes the best toilet seat, we looked at various criteria.

  • Performance: It’s important that a toilet seat withstands a lot of use, especially in homes with many residents. We made sure to select toilet seats with longevity and quality that holds up over time.
  • Durability: The majority of toilet seats are made from plastic or wood. Both of these materials last a long time, but we did our research and only selected products that can withstand increased usage and frequent lifting and lowering of the seat.
  • Installation: As many homeowners want to save costs on hiring professionals, it was paramount that we recommended toilet seats that are easy to install properly with minimal time and effort.
  • Cleanliness: A bathroom is a breeding ground for dirt and germs, which illustrates the importance of cleaning a toilet seat properly. We made sure that the products and materials we recommended are simple to clean.
  • Value: With something used daily, such as a toilet seat, finding value comes from how long a product lasts and how it performs as well as price. Our picks all focus on what you get for your money rather than just the cost of the item.

The Best Toilet Seats: Reviews and Recommendations

Best Overall: Kohler K-4639-0 Cachet Round White Toilet Seat

Suited for Any Bathroom

A tried-and-true choice from a leading brand. Kohler

Check Price

Why It Made The Cut: This familiar, reputable brand offers toilet seats that are affordable, easy to clean, and with an aesthetic that suits a majority of consumers. 

Specs:

  • Dimensions: 14.2 x 1.13 x 16.1 inches
  • Grip tight bumpers and slow close lid
  • Made of plastic material

Pros:

  • Quick release to clean
  • Slow close lid
  • Variety of colors
  • Bumpers to prevent sliding

Cons:

  • Plastic material may not appeal to all consumers

When it comes to toilet seats, consumers want a trustworthy, reliable product that lasts a long time. This Kohler toilet seat tops our list as the best overall for several reasons.

Kohler is a well-known brand in bathroom accessories and more, with a sterling reputation and a universal appeal. They’ve ranked in top spots for quality, brand recognition, and most used categories for their lines of everyday and luxury goods.

Their plastic toilet seat is a simple design done incredibly well. The toilet seat comes in either round or oval shapes and includes a quiet close lid, which is ideal for late night bathroom visits where you don’t want to wake up the whole house. Additionally, the bumpers on the seat help prevent shifting and allow for added stability, making it a terrific option for all users. 

Plastic is a very common material for toilet seats and offers perks that other materials may not, including durability and lower price point. This seat is made for fast installation that anyone can do. It comes with quick release hinges that remove the seat from the toilet for easy and thorough cleaning, helping prevent dirt and bacteria build up.

Lastly, this line offers a wide variety of colors, so consumers can select the one that seamlessly matches their bathroom decor. Not to worry, the hinges also match the seat, so they don’t stand out. 

Best Value: Mayfair 843SLOW 000 Lannon Toilet Seat

Budget Friendly

These enameled wooden seats are built to last at a great price. Mayfair

Check Price

Why It Made The Cut: This seat by Mayfair provides a slow close lid, comfort, and easy installation at a lower price point, offering exceptional value to the consumer. 

Specs:

  • Dimensions: 19.06 x 15.06 x 2.34 inches
  • Made of enameled wood
  • Slow close lid

Pros:

  • Slow close lid
  • Easy installation
  • Round or elongated options
  • Durable material

Cons:

  • Need to be careful with cleaning products

Mayfair by Bemis is a proudly American company that’s made these toilet seats in Wisconsin for over 60 years. With their established tenure, and use of sustainable materials and processes, consumers can be assured they’re investing in a quality product. 

Mayfair makes these durable, enameled wood toilet seats for comfort and longevity. Though they are made of wood, these seats look anything but rustic, so they’ll fit in a modern bathroom. The material holds up to scratches and dents and resists breaking or cracking. 

Features that we appreciate about this toilet seat include both round and elongated sizes to fit essentially any toilet; a slow close lid that won’t slam shut by accident; and a secure fastening system, so it won’t loosen over time and use

These come with a simple installation instruction sheet that outlines how to adjust the seat before attaching it so users get the perfect fit. The only tool required in installation is a wrench. The seat gets installed from the top, so pretty much anyone can do the work. The hardware is heavy-duty and stays in position once it’s properly installed.

One note of caution for interested consumers is to be mindful of cleaning products you use. Harsh chemicals will damage the enamel, so stick to cleaning with mild soap and water.

Best Padded Toilet Seat: Mayfair 15EC 047 Removable Soft

Extra Cushion

This comfortable toilet seat is easy to install and clean. Mayfair

Check Price

Why It Made The Cut: Mayfair has been a trusted name in toilet seat manufacturing for more than 60 years. This brand creates the best padded seat we found, as the soft vinyl material and construction deliver both comfort and easy cleaning.

Specs:  

  • Dimensions: 17.13 by 15 by 3.4 inches
  • Removable seat for easy cleaning
  • Durable vinyl cushion on a wood base

Pros:

  • Secure seat for stability
  • Easy installation
  • Round and elongated options
  • Several color options

Cons:

  • Shorter lifespan than non-padded toilet seats
  • No slow close feature

This Mayfair by Bemis cushioned toilet seat gives more support to users than traditional toilet seat styles. A soft padded toilet seat provides a bit more comfort and warmth, making it a wonderful choice for those seeking a bit more luxury, for the elderly, and for little ones who are toilet training and may need some added softness.

The seat is made of a wood core wrapped in easy-to-maintain vinyl. The outer material is durable and helps the seat last longer. In general, padded seats need to be replaced more often than hard toilet seats as the padding wears out from use over time. Many people are happy to make this tradeoff for comfort.

Some features we appreciate with this toilet seat include round and oval styles, enabling users to select the right one for their toilet; the use of sustainable materials, such as wood; and a secure fastening system that ensures the seat never comes loose from the bowl.

Some may point out that this seat lacks a slow close feature, however, it doesn’t need it. The seat’s padding absorbs the sound of the lid, so at most you hear the sound of a gentle thud.

In addition, you can install this toilet seat quickly and easily with only a wrench. It uses twist cap installation, so once it’s tightened sufficiently, the cap will twist off. A color-matched plastic hinge keeps the hardware hidden away. The hinge is made for easy cleaning, as it allows for simple removal of the seat, so you can tackle all the nooks and crannies. When it comes to cleaning the seat, avoid harsh chemicals and stick to mild soap and water.

These toilet seats are American-made and built to last. They come in a variety of colors, so you can select the one that matches your style best.

Best Wooden Toilet Seat: Design House 561241 Dalton Round Toilet Seat

Superior Durability

Made of oak and brass, this appealing toilet seat is also easy to install. Design House

Check Price

Why It Made The Cut: Many of the wood toilet seats we considered had a more rustic appeal with lower quality wood. Design House offers charming country style, made from solid oak wood that can hold up to 600 pounds.

Specs: 

  • Dimensions: 16.88 by 14.63 by 2.25 inches
  • Made from solid oak wood
  • Weight limit up to 600 pounds

Pros:

  • One tool installation
  • Durable wood
  • One-year warranty
  • A line of matching products from the manufacturer

Cons:

  • Wood may crack easier over time
  • May need to be replaced if aesthetic changes

Design House’s honey oak toilet seat works well with modern country or traditional country style. The solid oak wood construction is typically much more durable than plastic because it’s a thicker and heavier material. 

With a weight capacity of up to 600 pounds, this toilet seat proves its strength. However, there are natural lines in all wood products that can gradually crack over time, so you can’t expect this toilet seat to last forever. The manufacturer even throws in a one-year warranty, so consumers know that this addition to their bathroom is backed by the brand. 

The seat’s distinct wood appearance drastically changes the look of your bathroom. When decorating, mismatched wood accents can really detract from the aesthetic. Design House makes it easy to color match with their other products, such as a matching towel bar, towel ring, toilet paper hold, robe hooks, and more available for purchase. If you redecorate your bathroom, it’s possible a wood seat won’t match the update; if a bathroom overhaul is in the cards, you should do the updates before purchasing a wood toilet seat.

Installation of this toilet seat couldn’t be easier. Using just a screwdriver, it takes mere minutes to attach the standard mount to the toilet bowl. The brass hardware is incredibly durable and stands up to years of use.

Best Bidet Toilet Seat: American Standard 5900A05G.020 Non-Electric Bidet Seat

Extra Cleanliness

This pick incorporates a bidet to provide more options. American Standard

Check Price

Why It Made The Cut: American Standard’s toilet seat is the best quality bidet style for the price, featuring adjustable controls and nozzles for an individually customized experience.

Specs: 

  • Dimensions: 14.88 x 3.63 x 21.13 inches
  • Non-electric bidet feature with adjustable spray patterns
  • Slow close hinges

Pros:

  • Bidet functions
  • Slow close seat
  • No plug-in required
  • Top mounted install

Cons:

  • Fewer options than electric

Unlike traditional toilet seats consisting of only the seat and lid, American Standard’s oval-shaped toilet seat elevates a bathroom with the addition of a water-pressured bidet. The polypropylene plastic non-electric bidet that fits most standard toilets. Even without the use of electricity, this toilet seat enables users to customize the sprays with adjustable spray patterns and detachable nozzles, for a personalized washroom experience. 

Perks of using a water-pressured bidet over electric include that they’re more affordable; a straightforward, easy-to-use design; simpler installation; and potentially fewer repairs from having fewer mechanisms.

The streamlined design includes thoughtful construction. This model comes with a slow close seat, preventing it from slamming down and making loud noises. It can also be easily cleaned since there is a one button lift-off feature. The telescoping lid helps conceal the ring, making it look seamless and not bulky like a regular bidet. 

We also appreciate the easy top-mounted installation. This bidet comes with all the mounting hardware, and doesn’t require any specialty tools beyond the basics that are already in your home.

Best Toilet Seat for Parents: Mayfair Toilet Seat with Built-In Potty Training Seat

For Parents and Toddlers

This seat works for the whole family during potty training. Mayfair

Check Price

Why It Made The Cut: It was important to us to select an option for young families. We appreciate the trusted design of Mayfair’s built-in potty training seat, which allows parents and toddlers to conveniently use the same seat.

Specs: 

  • Dimensions: 16.81 by 14.38 by 2.19 inches
  • Has a built-in potty training seat
  • Slow close technology

Pros:

  • A helpful tool for families
  • Easy removal for cleaning
  • Slow close technology
  • No wiggle security

Cons:

  • Becomes less useful as children get older

There are few options out there for toilet seats that work for both adults and young children. With the Mayfair Toilet Seat with Built-In Potty Training Seat, the company  has made it much more convenient for families with toddlers to share a washroom and toilet train little ones without the fuss of a training potty.

This toilet seat is designed with a built-in child seat that can be flipped up when parents need to use the facilities. The child’s seat magnetically secures to the cover when not in use, so it stays out of the way. Made from durable enameled wood, this toilet seat comes in options for both round or elongated toilets (and three color options). This seat will serve you well for several years, but will likely be replaced with a standard toilet seat before this one wears out.

Safety comes built-in, so parents can be assured these seats aren’t a danger for their little ones. The design features:

  • Slow close technology that prevents fingers from getting pinched and startling noises that can be unsettling for children
  • A no shift seat, so parents can be confident that the toilet seat won’t wiggle while it’s in use.

With quick installation using only a wrench, the seat can be adjusted to fit your toilet just right. When it’s bathroom cleaning day, the seat can be removed for a thorough clean (which is needed frequently in the potty training years).

Things to Consider Before Buying a Toilet Seat

Toilet seats aren’t universal; they all have their unique qualities that have to fit your home and preferences. Before you select a new toilet seat, there are some considerations you need to think about.

Toilet Seat Size

Traditionally, there are two different types of toilet seats, elongated (oval) and round. Take a look at what kind of seat you have currently, and purchase your new seat in the same style. If you accidentally purchase the wrong size, you may still be able to attach it to your toilet, but it will not fit properly. Save yourself the trouble and know what you need before you place your order.

Material

You may dismiss material quickly, but it’s worth weighing your options. Most toilet seats you find are either plastic or wood, but there are resin seats, vinyl padded seats, and more available. Each material has their own benefits and drawbacks, so carefully consider your needs and wants.

User Demographic

Most folks can use a standard toilet seat just fine, but others may have special requirements. For example, elderly folks may prefer a padded seat or homes with small children may want a seat that uses safe, slow close technology.

Toilet Compatibility

Whether you have a bidet or smart toilet, you need to find out if you require a special toilet seat. Some more upscale toilets may not be compatible with standard toilet seats. If you’re unsure, do a little research on your toilet and find out what the manufacturer recommends.

FAQs

Q: Do all toilet seats fit the same?

No, not all toilet seats fit the same. Toilets come in a variety of different shapes. The two most common types in North America are elongated (oval) and round.

Q: How do I know what toilet seat will fit my toilet?

Look at what type of toilet you have installed in your home. Round toilets are shorter and usually placed in smaller bathrooms. Elongated toilets are longer and take up more space.

Q: What are the different sizes of toilet seats?

For the two different toilet seat sizes in North America, elongated seats are 18.5 inches long and the round seats are 16.5 inches long.

Final Thoughts

A toilet seat should last you many years and be a comfortable place for everyone in the house. With a timeless aesthetic, agreeable design, consumer appeal, and reputable brand, Kohler K-4639-0 Cachet Round White Toilet Seat is one that many would choose for their home.

MORE TO READ